Value-Based Care Transparency Snapshot (U.S.)

A structured review of publicly reported outcome claims and documentation patterns. Currently covering 10 VBC enablement companies. Dataset updated on a rolling basis.

Scores measure how explicitly a company documents its outcome claims - not whether outcomes are good.

For: health plan procurement, ACO contract evaluation, and analyst research.

Showing 10 of 10.

CompanyPopulation / CustomerTransparency ScoreDetails
agilon health

Medicare Advantage

Provider groups

4/5

Score breakdown

Transparency score: 4/5

Evidence snippets: 8

High confidence snippets: 2

Business model

Partners with primary care groups to take full-risk Medicare Advantage contracts. Shares risk and upside with physician partners.

Segment

Enablement / ACO

Evidence cards

Peer-reviewedConfidence 5/52023

Palliative care is associated with improved patient outcomes including $10,393 lower overall healthcare costs

100% confidence weightcostSource
Peer-reviewedConfidence 5/52023

patients enrolled in a primary care-led, integrated palliative care program spent an average of five more days at home during their final months (133.5 versus 128.23; p<.001) and were almost two-thirds less likely to die in a hospital (9 percent versus 26 percent; p<.001)

100% confidence weightqualitySource
Press releaseConfidence 3/52025

Senior patients managed by women PCPs experienced better key clinical outcomes and less healthcare utilization compared to patients seen by men PCPs.

60% confidence weightqualitySource
Press releaseConfidence 3/52025

After shifting to VBC, PCPs saw eight more new TM patients per year compared to the matched cohort of physicians who did not transition to the full-risk model, representing an approximate 35% relative increase in new TM patient volume.

60% confidence weightutilizationSource
Press releaseConfidence 3/52025

New Study Finds Senior Patients Managed by Women Physicians in a Value-Based Care (VBC) Model Have Equal or Better Clinical and Quality Outcomes and Less Healthcare Utilization

60% confidence weightqualitySource
OtherConfidence 2/52023

health screenings in value-based care are estimated to be between 8% and 20% higher than in FFS models

40% confidence weightqualitySource
OtherConfidence 2/52023

Up to 38% fewer hospitalizations through early detection and timely intervention

40% confidence weightutilizationSource
OtherConfidence 1/52023

agilon health does not provide any quantifiable outcome claims in the provided snippets.

20% confidence weightutilizationSource
Aledade

Multi-payer

Provider groups

4/5

Score breakdown

Transparency score: 4/5

Evidence snippets: 9

High confidence snippets: 3

Business model

Physician-led ACO network. Shares upside savings with independent primary care practices in MSSP.

Segment

Enablement / ACO

Evidence cards

CMSConfidence 5/52026

In 2026, Aledade is serving 1 in 5 of all new MSSP participants and nearly 20% of the total MSSP program.

100% confidence weightutilizationSource
CMSConfidence 5/52024

75% of ACOs earned performance payments totaling $4.1 billion while generating $2.4 billion in savings for Medicare.

100% confidence weightcostSource
CMSConfidence 5/52023

The Medicare Shared Savings Program generated an estimated $1.8 billion in total savings in 2022.

100% confidence weightqualitySource
Press releaseConfidence 3/52026

Aledade earned the highest national score of 95.7 out of 100

60% confidence weightqualitySource
OtherConfidence 3/52023

In 2023, Aledade partners conducted 50% more Annual Wellness Visits than the average practice.

60% confidence weightutilizationSource
OtherConfidence 3/52023

Accredo’s TRC model helped achieve 22% fewer inpatient admissions

60% confidence weightutilizationSource
Press releaseConfidence 2/52026

In the most recent MSSP performance year, 93% of Aledade’s accountable care organizations achieved savings, and together Aledade generated more than $1 billion in total savings.

40% confidence weightcostSource
Press releaseConfidence 2/52026

Aledade Partners Achieve Superior Hypertension Control, Outperforming Large Health Systems in New Case Study

40% confidence weightutilizationSource
Press releaseConfidence 2/52024

In 2024, the Medicare Shared Savings Program (MSSP) — the nation's largest value-based care program — saved Medicare more than $2.4 billion, its largest savings in history.

40% confidence weightcostSource
Alignment Healthcare

Medicare Advantage

Health plans

4/5

Score breakdown

Transparency score: 4/5

Evidence snippets: 7

High confidence snippets: 3

Business model

Medicare Advantage plan focused on complex, high-need seniors. Takes full insurance risk. Employs clinical staff to manage highest-cost members.

Segment

Payer / Medicare Advantage

Evidence cards

SEC filingConfidence 5/52025

Chronic members comprise 14% of our membership but account for 78% of the institutional claims submitted.

100% confidence weightutilizationSource
Peer-reviewedConfidence 5/52025

Generalist-led hospital models have emerged as a potential approach to achieving value-based care goals.

100% confidence weightqualitySource
CMSConfidence 5/52024

100% of our 210,000+ members enrolled in our personalized care models and real-time data insights.

100% confidence weightqualitySource
OtherConfidence 2/52026

Alignment Health Plan earned an overall 5-star rating for its H5296 Medicare Advantage (MA) HMO contract in Nevada and North Carolina.

40% confidence weightqualitySource
OtherConfidence 2/52023

One independent physicians group (IPA) in Mississippi realized a 12% reduction in hospitalizations for patients in chronic care management (CCM) programs, 25% fewer hospital readmissions and $66 million in Medicare savings since 2016.

40% confidence weightutilizationSource
Press releaseConfidence 2/52023

Alignment Healthcare achieved a 20% reduction in hospital readmission rates through their innovative model.

40% confidence weightutilizationSource
OtherConfidence 1/52026

we can reduce unnecessary complexity and help lower the total cost of care.

20% confidence weightqualitySource
Astrana Health

Multi-payer

Provider groups

3/5

Score breakdown

Transparency score: 3/5

Evidence snippets: 6

High confidence snippets: 1

Business model

IPA network and MSO operating primarily in California. Manages capitated contracts across Medicare, Medicaid, and commercial.

Segment

Enablement / ACO

Evidence cards

SEC filingConfidence 5/52025

In the Medicare Shared Savings Program, the company achieved 6% savings compared to the previous year.

100% confidence weightutilizationSource
OtherConfidence 2/52025

Total revenue of $3,181.8 million, up 56% from $2,034.5 million

40% confidence weightqualitySource
Press releaseConfidence 2/52026

approximately 80% of Care Partners capitation revenue and approximately 40% of consolidated membership now in full-risk arrangements

40% confidence weightutilizationSource
Press releaseConfidence 2/52025

This acquisition is projected to boost annual revenue by $1.2 billion.

40% confidence weightcostSource
OtherConfidence 2/52024

Astrana Health has successfully operated for 35+ years to empower entrepreneurial providers with tools to deliver a higher level of care.

40% confidence weightqualitySource
Press releaseConfidence 1/52026

Foothill Regional Medical Center Receives 2026 Patient Safety Excellence Award™ from Healthgrades

20% confidence weightqualitySource
CareSource

Medicaid

Government payers

5/5

Score breakdown

Transparency score: 5/5

Evidence snippets: 5

High confidence snippets: 3

Business model

Nonprofit managed care plan focused on Medicaid and marketplace populations. Takes full insurance risk in government programs.

Segment

Payer / Medicaid

Evidence cards

CMSConfidence 5/52023

Members served through a Value Based Care program had 16% fewer ER visits, and Well Child visits increased by 44%. Overall costs for these members were 28% lower per member/per month.

100% confidence weightqualitySource
Peer-reviewedConfidence 5/52023

This protocol paper describes an effectiveness-implementation trial evaluating community suicide prevention practices triggered by advances in informatics that alert CareSource, a large managed care organization (MCO), when a subscriber is released from jail.

100% confidence weightqualitySource
Peer-reviewedConfidence 5/52023

This randomized controlled trial investigates two evidence-based suicide prevention practices triggered by CareSource's jail detention/release notifications, in a partial factorial design.

100% confidence weightqualitySource
Press releaseConfidence 2/52026

CareSource’s $1.5 Million Donation to Dayton Children’s Hospital Aims to Improve Access to Pediatric Care in West Dayton

40% confidence weightqualitySource
Press releaseConfidence 2/52023

15% more children complete all seven recommended vaccinations for 2-year-olds

40% confidence weightqualitySource
Clover Health

Medicare Advantage

Health plans

5/5

Score breakdown

Transparency score: 5/5

Evidence snippets: 4

High confidence snippets: 3

Business model

Medicare Advantage plan using proprietary software platform to support physician decision-making. Takes full insurance risk.

Segment

Payer / Medicare Advantage

Evidence cards

Peer-reviewedConfidence 5/52023

Patients discharged home from SNFs with HHC had lower 30-day readmission rates.

100% confidence weightutilizationSource
CMSConfidence 5/52023

The program reduced hospital readmissions by 10% in the past year.

100% confidence weightutilizationSource
Case studyConfidence 4/52023

Clover Health PPO Medicare Advantage Plan achieved 4.94 out of 5 Stars on HEDIS measures for Star Rating year 2025 (MY2023).

80% confidence weightqualitySource
Press releaseConfidence 2/52026

Clover Health's MA membership grows 51% year-over-year.

40% confidence weightutilizationSource
Evolent Health

Multi-payer

Health plans

2/5

Score breakdown

Transparency score: 2/5

Evidence snippets: 8

High confidence snippets: 0

Business model

Partners with payers and health systems to manage specialty care costs. Earns fees for reducing low-value specialty utilization.

Segment

Specialty Care Management

Evidence cards

Press releaseConfidence 3/52025

Average PMPM Fees/ Revenue per Case $13.87

60% confidence weightutilizationSource
OtherConfidence 3/52024

Evolent Care Partners had a shared savings rate of 5.9% in 2024, which — although decent — is lower than Privia’s 9.3% savings rate across its ACOs.

60% confidence weightutilizationSource
Press releaseConfidence 3/52023

Evolent program achieves 20% reduction in use of low-value oncology regimens

60% confidence weightqualitySource
Case studyConfidence 3/52023

Evolent Health achieved a 95% call answer rate.

60% confidence weightutilizationSource
OtherConfidence 2/52026

Nearly 1 in 3 Medicare beneficiaries sees five or more physicians annually.

40% confidence weightqualitySource
OtherConfidence 2/52025

Evolent’s scale—managing care for over 5 million lives—creates a data flywheel that improves algorithms and outcomes.

40% confidence weightutilizationSource
Press releaseConfidence 2/52025

ECP is a leading participant in the Medicare Shared Savings Program ('MSSP'), partnering with more than 1,000 physicians across the nation to serve more than 120,000 members.

40% confidence weightutilizationSource
OtherConfidence 1/52024

Improve quality while managing costs in our ACO for independent providers

20% confidence weightqualitySource
Molina Healthcare

Multi-payer

Health plans

4/5

Score breakdown

Transparency score: 4/5

Evidence snippets: 4

High confidence snippets: 3

Business model

Publicly traded managed care plan operating Medicaid, Medicare, and marketplace plans across multiple states. Takes full insurance risk.

Segment

Payer / Managed Care

Evidence cards

SEC filingConfidence 5/52023

The company achieved a 15% reduction in readmission rates year-over-year.

100% confidence weightutilizationSource
Peer-reviewedConfidence 5/52023

A total of 278 alternative therapy interventions were made with an estimated cost savings of $133,191.43.

100% confidence weightcostSource
Third party auditConfidence 4/52025

Molina Healthcare revenue for the quarter ending December 31, 2025 was

80% confidence weightutilizationSource
OtherConfidence 2/52025

Molina Healthcare reports Medicare Advantage Membership grew from 258,000 to 260,000 - YoY.

40% confidence weightutilizationSource
Oak Street Health

Medicare Advantage

Health plans

5/5

Score breakdown

Transparency score: 5/5

Evidence snippets: 4

High confidence snippets: 3

Business model

Employed-physician primary care clinics focused on Medicare patients. Now part of CVS Health. Takes full capitation risk.

Segment

Primary Care / Risk-bearing

Evidence cards

CMSConfidence 5/52024

Oak Street Health’s approach led to a 44% reduction in hospital admissions compared to Medicare benchmarks.

100% confidence weightutilizationSource
CMSConfidence 5/52023

The ACO improved patient satisfaction scores by 15%.

100% confidence weightqualitySource
CMSConfidence 5/52023

The program aims for 90% of providers to meet quality benchmarks by year-end.

100% confidence weightqualitySource
OtherConfidence 1/52023

Oak Street Health focuses on delivering high-quality care through a value-based care model.

20% confidence weightqualitySource
Privia Health

Multi-payer

Provider groups

4/5

Score breakdown

Transparency score: 4/5

Evidence snippets: 8

High confidence snippets: 3

Business model

Technology-enabled physician practice management. Helps practices participate in VBC contracts across commercial, Medicare, and Medicaid.

Segment

Enablement / ACO

Evidence cards

CMSConfidence 5/52024

Privia ACOs Delivered $233+ Million in Total Savings in the 2024 Performance Year of Medicare Shared Savings Program, a 32% Year-over-Year Increase

100% confidence weightcostSource
SEC filingConfidence 5/52024

Privia operated nine ACOs that delivered care to more than 194,000 Medicare beneficiaries through MSSP, achieving shared savings of $233.1 million, an increase of 32% over 2023.

100% confidence weightcostSource
Case studyConfidence 4/52026

about 15 percent of all appointments with Privia providers are scheduled through this functionality each month.

80% confidence weightutilizationSource
Press releaseConfidence 3/52026

Privia Health’s EHR Cancer Screening Gains Put Value Based Story In Focus

60% confidence weightqualitySource
Press releaseConfidence 3/52025

Privia Health Reports Third Quarter 2025 Financial Results

60% confidence weightqualitySource
OtherConfidence 2/52023

Privia’s generating savings in the MSSP for 10 consecutive years.

40% confidence weightcostSource
OtherConfidence 2/52023

The company achieved a 30% reduction in hospital readmission rates.

40% confidence weightqualitySource
OtherConfidence 1/52025

Make 2025 the year you thrive in value-based care.

20% confidence weightqualitySource

Methodology

v1.1 - Last updated: May 30, 2026

Confidence scores are generated by a deterministic rubric (v1.1) in the tooling layer. The board displays those scores as provided in the dataset; it does not re-score in the UI.

Scoring Rubric (v1.1)

The transparency score is composed of source reliability baseline and explicit documentation signals.

Source TypeBase Score
CMS / Public datasets5
Peer-reviewed publication4
SEC filing / regulated disclosure4
Third-party audit4
Third-party analyst report / white paper with methodology / conference abstract3
Case study2
Press release1
Other1

Limitations

  • The score evaluates transparency and reporting detail, not causal validity or clinical effectiveness.
  • The board uses extracted fields from linked sources and can inherit source omissions or ambiguity.
  • Merge deduplication removes exact duplicates by company + claim + year + URL; near-duplicates may remain.
  • Company ordering is deterministic but case-sensitive, and does not imply ranking.
  • Companies control what they publish. vbcbench can only evaluate claims that appear in public sources. Outcomes that were never reported, studies that showed no effect, and performance in non-public contracts are not captured here.
  • A verifiable claim is not the same as a meaningful one. A statistically significant result in a small population may not translate to clinical impact at scale. vbcbench scores source quality, not effect size or clinical relevance.
  • Coverage is uneven by design. Companies with robust investor relations teams, public listings, and active communications departments will naturally generate more indexable claims than smaller or private organizations. Higher scores may reflect reporting sophistication as much as outcome quality.

Corrections Policy

Submit corrections through the Contact form with inquiry type Data correction. Include the company name, source URL, and the specific field or claim that should be changed.

Corrections are reviewed on a rolling basis and incorporated in subsequent data updates.

Contact

Corrections, partnerships, and custom comparative analysis upon request.

This form opens your email client (mailto: hello@vbcbench.com).

© 2026 VBC Bench. Independently curated.

v1.0 – March 2026